Join TrustSquare | Sign In
SITE SEARCH
Review Center  
Write Review  
Rate Reviews  
Read Reviews  
Write Comments  
Read All Reviews   
Writer  


Mail
 
 
Recommended  


BLACK
Moving away from the usual song and dance films, Sanjay Leela Bhansali's new film "BLACK" starring Amitabh Bachchan and Rani Mukharjee in the lead role. The film is all about a deaf and blind girl and
Rating:
 
Recommendation:
 
   Product Rating  Product Rating
Category Entertainment  Movies  BLACK
Date Posted 2/23/2005 7:17:27 PM
Recommendations Nisha Nisha   Recommends   BLACK
 Review Title : Black Hits: 77 

If you watch one movie this year, let that movie be Black. Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s Black is a passionate and powerful cinematic experience. From the outset of the film, the audience is taken on an emotional journey in an epic proportion. xml:namespace prefix = o ns = "urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:office" />

 

Black is a tribute to the renowned blind and deaf laureate, Helen Keller. Bhansali offers his interpretation of the unique relationship between Helen Keller and her teacher Annie Sullivan. In Black, Bhansali replaces Sullivan for Debraj Sahai (Amitabh Bachchan), and the Keller’s remarkable life is portrayed by Rani Mukerji, as Michelle McNally.  

 

“Life is like an ice-cream; enjoy it before it melts away”. This is what Sahai teaches his student McNally. Sahai plays a teacher who has to come to terms with his own impending blackness –the profession he so loves and has made his life, is drawing to an end. The principle at the school he teaches at, receives a letter from Michelle’s desperate mother, who has heard about the prowess of Sahai’s teaching. The principle realises this is Sahai’s opportunity to remain a teacher and suggests he take up the offer to help Michelle.

 

Sahai arrives at the McNally’s – but Michelle’s father does not approve of his eccentric teaching methods. The young actress who plays Michelle (Ayesha Kapoor) delivers a convincing performance. Her portrayal of a young girl suffocating in her blackness is nothing short of spectacular. Michelle’s mother (Shernaz Patel) allows Sahai to help her daughter and it is during Sahai’s unusual teaching sessions that Kapoor blossoms in her performance.  

 

The narrative structure then revolves around the relationship between teacher and pupil, and as the years move on, the lines between the teacher-pupil relationship become blurred.

 

Apart from dealing with the complexities of the teacher-pupil relationship, the film also attempts to deal with the themes of sibling rivalry and burgeoning femininity. However, Bhansali touches on these aspects fleetingly and one is left feeling bereft. Perhaps his camera could have lingered a little longer….?

 

The film is wonderfully conceptualised, with a beautiful storyline. The cinematography, costume and overall ambience of the film lent an aesthetic feel to the overall picture. Something which I personally found lacking was the absence of a sense of time and to an extent, location. This could have possibly, been a deliberate move on the part of the director to make it more timeless and thus, less - ephemeral.

 

I walked away from the theatre, with the realisation that acting is not only about the spoken word. Acting is also about movement – of the body, the eyes, the soul. And this is what Mukerji portrays brilliantly. She portrays the soul of a girl trapped in her own blackness.

 

The absence of sight, sound and speech in Michelle’s life alters the communication patterns of those around her. The audience then; actually feels a heightened sense of awareness. It is almost as if we can feel the blackness, hear the blackness and smell the blackness that envelops the audience throughout the film’s emotive journey. At the end of the film, one realises that although black is traditionally used to connote darkness, one should appreciate the many colours that make up ‘the black’.

 

 

 

Summary Information
The Good Excellent performances Great cinematography
The Bad Lack of development of certain themes
Other Information
Story Good
Acting Excellent
Screen Play Good
Music Good
  • Average Review Rating :   2(Out Of 5)
  • Number of Votes : 4
  • Posted By : Nisha Nisha
  • TS User ID : mirchi (1035)

Comments On This Review
CommentsMemberDate Posted
Hey nisha, excellent review :-)
I was myself thinking of writing on black but wasn't sure if i'd be able to do justice to this wonderful movie, but you have done a marvelous job of it. I have done 2-3 paras.. wud post mine soon..
Tulika
Bittu2/24/2005 7:08:38 AM
Excellent Review and all points well summarized. Such reviews really help user know about a product. Please keep writing more on various products, we would be well educated by thesechawlars2/24/2005 1:02:14 PM
It was a real difficult review to write and you have done a fantastic job. Congrats!!!!!!!!! Munishkohli_munish2/27/2005 12:47:24 PM
Hey Nisha...this is an excellent review. I've been wanting to watch the movie after seeing the promos and reading the rave reviews in the press but your veiws on it really make me want to watch it more. Keep up the great work.joanne2/28/2005 11:26:52 PM
1

  
Read More Reviews On BLACK








Google Search
Google
©2004 alehigado.com All rights reserved
Site map alehigado.com - Consumer reviews, opinions on mobile phones, cars, travel, stores, movies & thousands of other products and services Products